Ada Ogbu
A critical assessment of Chinyeaka Ohaa’s ‘Rescue Mission’ manifesto

The central weakness of Sir Chinyeaka Ohaa’s manifesto is that it makes a great deal of noise about rescuing Enugu State but offers considerably less clarity about how that rescue would actually be achieved. It is heavy on declarations, committees, promises, accusations and deadlines, but light on the hard policy details that distinguish a credible governing programme from an election campaign document.

A manifesto is not simply a catalogue of everything a candidate believes is wrong with an incumbent administration. It should explain what the candidate intends to do differently, why the proposed alternatives are workable, how much they will cost, where the money will come from, which institutions will implement them, what legal constraints apply and how citizens will measure success.

On those tests, Ohaa’s The Rescue Mission, 2027 raises more questions than it answers.

Its most striking feature is the contrast between the scale of its promises and the absence of the financial, technical and institutional framework required to deliver them. It promises 24-hour electricity, 24-hour water, 24-hour healthcare in every ward, 260 solar-powered water schemes, three agro-industrial corridors, three ranching facilities, extensive road construction, market compensation, pension reforms and tax relief. Yet it provides no cost estimates, financing plan, revenue projections, implementation architecture or clear prioritisation of these competing commitments.

That is not a minor omission. It goes to the heart of whether the manifesto is a serious development blueprint or an aspirational political document.

1. It diagnoses problems without establishing the evidence

The manifesto opens by presenting a long list of alleged governance failures: multiple taxation, land acquisition and displacement, questionable public-private partnerships, rising public debt, unpaid retirement benefits, rural neglect, unfulfilled public utilities promises, misplaced development priorities, defective Smart Green Schools and political intimidation.

These are serious allegations. But the candidate does not provide the supporting evidence needed to make them persuasive.

Where are the figures showing the scale of multiple taxation? Which public-private partnerships are considered questionable, what are the specific concerns, and what evidence supports those concerns? Which land acquisitions are alleged to have been unlawful? How much debt does the candidate consider excessive, and what proportion of the state’s revenue is currently committed to debt servicing? Which schools have defective infrastructure, and what independent assessment establishes this?

The manifesto repeatedly uses politically charged descriptions such as “white elephant projects”, “reckless land acquisition”, “opaque government transactions” and “misplaced development priorities”. Yet it does not identify the projects, transactions, locations or decisions behind these descriptions.

This is where the document begins to look less like a policy alternative and more like a political indictment of the incumbent administration.

A credible opposition candidate is entitled to criticise the government, but criticism becomes constructive when it is supported by facts and followed by a convincing alternative. Simply labelling government projects wasteful or defective does not establish that they are so. Nor does it explain what the candidate would do differently.

The manifesto would have been much stronger if it had presented a concise assessment of Enugu’s current economic and social indicators, identified specific policy failures and explained how its proposed interventions would improve on existing arrangements.

2. The economic promises lack a financial foundation

Perhaps the most consequential weakness is the absence of a costed implementation plan.

The candidate promises an extensive programme involving electricity generation, water infrastructure, road construction, market recovery, compensation, agriculture, industrialisation, healthcare, education, security and social protection.

These are not inexpensive interventions. They require substantial capital expenditure, recurrent funding, technical expertise and sustained institutional capacity.

Yet nowhere does the manifesto provide an estimated cost for any of its major programmes. It does not state how much the proposed electricity programme would require, the cost of establishing 260 solar-powered water schemes, the financial implications of upgrading 260 primary healthcare centres to round-the-clock operations, or the amount required to clear inherited gratuity liabilities within 24 months.

It does not even provide a broad estimate of the total financial resources required to implement the Rescue Mission.

More importantly, the manifesto does not explain how the proposed expenditure would be financed.

Would the administration depend on internally generated revenue, federal allocations, borrowing, private investment, development finance institutions or public-private partnerships? If borrowing is contemplated, what debt limits would guide the administration? If private investors are expected to finance infrastructure, what returns or incentives would make the investments attractive?

The promise to move from excessive taxation to enterprise-driven growth is politically attractive, but it is not a substitute for a revenue strategy. A government cannot simultaneously promise extensive tax relief, large-scale infrastructure expansion, improved public services and accelerated debt repayment without explaining how it intends to balance the books.

The candidate cannot credibly condemn public borrowing and, at the same time, promise capital-intensive projects without showing how they will be financed.

3. The 24-hour electricity promise is more slogan than strategy

One of the boldest promises is to establish state-owned independent power plants capable of delivering affordable, uninterrupted 24-hour electricity to homes, businesses and industries across Enugu State.

The manifesto invokes Ohaa’s experience as a former Permanent Secretary in the Federal Ministry of Power and promises to consult former Ministers of Power, Prof. Barth Nnaji and Prof. Chinedu Nebo.

But the presence of experienced professionals in a proposed advisory arrangement does not amount to an electricity policy.

Where will the power plants be located? What will their generation capacity be? Will they be gas-fired, coal-fired, solar-based or a combination of energy sources? How much will construction cost? Where will the gas or other fuel come from? What arrangements will be made for transmission and distribution? What will consumers pay? How will the state-owned facilities recover their operating costs and finance maintenance?

The manifesto does not answer these basic questions.

It also fails to explain how the proposed state-owned generation programme will fit into the existing electricity market and the regulatory framework governing generation, distribution, licensing and power supply.

The candidate cannot simply announce 24-hour electricity as an objective and expect voters to accept it as an achievable policy.

Enugu needs a credible energy strategy, not a promise that sounds impressive but is unsupported by generation targets, financing arrangements, regulatory considerations and a realistic implementation timetable.

4. The water promise is ambitious but internally inconsistent

The manifesto promises to ensure that households in Enugu and other cities enjoy uninterrupted water supply within three years. It also promises a functional solar-powered water scheme in each of the state’s 260 wards by the end of Year Three.

These are two different commitments, but the document does not explain how they will work together.

A solar-powered borehole or water scheme in every ward does not automatically translate into reliable household water supply. Water infrastructure requires dependable water sources, treatment facilities, storage, reticulation networks, maintenance arrangements and a system for managing distribution.

Who will operate the 260 schemes? Who will maintain the pumps and replace faulty components? How will water quality be monitored? Will the schemes be connected to existing distribution networks or operate as independent community facilities? What happens in densely populated urban areas where a ward-level scheme may be inadequate for the number of households?

The manifesto provides no technical assessment, cost estimates or maintenance framework.

It is particularly striking that a candidate who describes the water crisis as an intractable challenge offers no baseline assessment of existing water infrastructure, no estimate of the current supply deficit and no explanation of the investments required to close that gap.

The promise is therefore more of an aspiration than an implementation-ready policy.

5. The healthcare proposal ignores the realities of staffing and funding

The commitment to upgrade at least one primary healthcare centre in every ward to 24-hour service is another example of a promise whose operational implications have not been considered.

Enugu has 260 wards. A 24-hour healthcare facility requires more than a building, beds and medical equipment. It needs doctors, nurses, midwives, laboratory personnel, pharmacists, security, electricity, water, medicines, emergency response arrangements and a dependable recurrent budget.

Does the state currently have enough healthcare workers to staff 260 facilities around the clock? If not, how many additional personnel would be recruited? What would their salaries and allowances cost? How would the administration prevent the upgraded facilities from becoming buildings with inadequate staff and equipment?

The manifesto does not say.

It also fails to identify whether the proposed 24-hour facilities would be new investments, upgrades of existing primary healthcare centres or a combination of both.

A more credible approach would have been to establish a phased programme, beginning with an audit of existing facilities, staffing gaps, service utilisation and geographical needs, followed by a costed plan for upgrading and sustaining them.

6. The market recovery promise raises questions about fairness and feasibility

The candidate proposes establishing an independent Market Traders Recovery Committee within seven days of assuming office to investigate demolitions and document affected traders at Ogige Nsukka, Garriki, Holy Ghost and Abakpa markets, as well as the Nnamdi Azikiwe Stadium.

The proposal promises preliminary findings within 30 days, independent compensation assessments within 60 days, emergency assistance and temporary or replacement trading spaces within 90 days, and an independently audited recovery fund.

On the surface, this appears compassionate. But the manifesto does not establish the scope of the alleged losses, the number of affected traders, the legal circumstances surrounding the demolitions or the criteria for determining compensation.

It also groups markets and the Nnamdi Azikiwe Stadium together without explaining the particular trading activities or affected interests at the stadium that would qualify for the proposed intervention.

Who qualifies for compensation? Would compensation cover only traders with verifiable ownership or tenancy documents, or would informal traders also qualify? How would the committee distinguish legitimate claims from inflated or fraudulent ones? Would compensation be paid to individuals, business owners, shop occupants or all categories of affected persons?

Most importantly, how much money would be placed in the recovery fund, and from which budgetary source?

The candidate appears to have settled on a compensation programme before establishing the actual liabilities.

A responsible policy should begin with an independent audit, transparent eligibility criteria, legal assessment and a properly funded mechanism. It should not create expectations of compensation that the next administration may be unable to meet.

7. The land policy is contradictory and potentially problematic

The manifesto promises to review Executive Order No. 1 of 2025 and the Land Use Regulation 2025, reduce land-related charges, protect property rights and prevent arbitrary displacement.

It then proposes free land allocation to qualifying investors under a 24-month special business land directive, with investors required to achieve at least 60 per cent structural development or operational deployment within 24 months, failing which the property would “unconditionally” revert to the state.

This raises several questions.

First, what does the candidate consider excessive about the existing land charges? Which charges would be abolished, reduced or retained? What would be the fiscal consequences of the proposed reductions?

Second, what criteria would determine which investors qualify for free land? Would the allocation be based on the number of jobs to be created, the amount of capital invested, the sector involved or the economic value of the proposed project?

Third, what does 60 per cent structural development mean? Is it 60 per cent of the building’s physical construction, the total project investment or the proposed operational capacity?

The provision that land would “unconditionally” revert to the state is especially troubling. Land allocation, revocation and reversion cannot responsibly be reduced to an arbitrary political deadline. They must be governed by clear contractual terms, due process, applicable land laws and fair procedures for resolving disputes.

There is also a contradiction in promising to protect property rights while proposing a loosely defined reversion mechanism that could create uncertainty for investors.

A candidate seeking to attract investment should be particularly careful not to introduce provisions that could undermine confidence in the security of land rights.

8. The agriculture and livestock proposals lack an agricultural value-chain strategy

The proposal to establish three agro-industrial corridors, one in each senatorial district, is potentially useful. The manifesto identifies crops suited to the respective zones and proposes three modern ranching and livestock-processing facilities.

However, identifying crops is not the same as developing an agricultural economy.

Where are the proposed corridors to be located? How much land would be required? What arrangements would be made for land acquisition and community consent? What irrigation facilities, rural roads, storage systems, processing plants and agricultural extension services would support production?

How would farmers access affordable seeds, fertilisers, mechanisation, credit and insurance? Who would buy the produce? What market arrangements would prevent farmers from suffering losses during periods of excess production?

The livestock proposal is even less developed. The candidate introduces an “Odalije Ranching Model” without explaining what the model entails, how it differs from existing ranching approaches, how it would be financed or how it would address land ownership, animal health, feed supply, environmental concerns and possible farmer-herder conflicts.

A serious agricultural policy must cover the entire value chain: production, processing, storage, transportation, marketing and export opportunities.

Without these details, the proposed corridors and ranches remain attractive labels rather than viable development programmes.

9. The pension proposal needs evidence, not emotional language

The manifesto promises to establish an Enugu State Retirees Gratuity Redemption Fund, audit outstanding liabilities, publish a retirees’ register and clear inherited gratuity arrears within 24 months.

It also proposes a retirement benefits processing centre and says gratuities should preferably be paid alongside the final salary.

These are important issues, particularly for retirees who have waited years for their entitlements. But the candidate does not provide the figures needed to demonstrate the scale of the problem or the feasibility of the proposed solution.

How much is owed to retirees? How many people are affected? What is the breakdown by retirement year and category of service? How much would the state need to pay every month to clear the arrears within 24 months? What portion of the state’s annual revenue would be committed to the programme?

The claim that some pensioners receive as little as ₦447 monthly is particularly striking. But the manifesto provides no source, date, pension category or explanation of the circumstances behind that figure. Is it a verified current payment, an isolated case, an old record or a reference to a particular pension arrangement?

Such a serious claim should be accompanied by verifiable evidence.

There is also an important omission: the manifesto does not acknowledge or assess existing government efforts to address gratuity liabilities. Enugu State has already announced a ₦10 billion gratuity intervention covering different categories of retirees, with payments made to successive batches. A credible opposition proposal should examine what has been done, identify what remains outstanding and explain how its proposed fund would improve on the existing arrangement.

Simply promising to clear inherited arrears within two years, without stating the verified liability or the funding mechanism, is not enough.

The proposed consequential pension adjustments also require clarification. What formula would determine the adjustments? Which pension categories would qualify? How would the state finance the additional recurrent expenditure?

Retirees deserve a sustainable payment framework, not another promise that may become an inherited liability for the next administration.

10. The education proposal is short on detail and long on insinuation

The candidate proposes an independent review of the Smart Green Schools programme, rehabilitation of existing schools, improved teacher recruitment and training, and a review of the transfer of public schools to missionary owners.

The manifesto claims that 1,007 public schools had been returned to their original missionary owners as of 2009 and promises to complete the handover of outstanding issues.

But what exactly remains outstanding after all these years? Which schools are affected? Which missionary organisations are involved? What legal agreements govern the ownership and management of the schools? What responsibilities would the state retain?

The proposed Government-Church Education Partnership and dedicated mission schools development fund also need much more detail.

Would the state pay teachers’ salaries in mission-owned schools? Would it fund infrastructure in privately managed institutions? What accountability mechanisms would ensure that public funds are used appropriately? How would admission policies, affordability and access for children from different backgrounds be protected?

The proposed review of Smart Green Schools is similarly vague. Which aspects of the programme are defective? Is the concern about construction quality, location, equipment, staffing, curriculum or maintenance? What does the candidate intend to retain, modify or discontinue?

A manifesto should not merely promise to review an incumbent’s project. It should explain the standards against which the project would be assessed and the policy alternative if deficiencies are established.

11. The rural development promise needs a clearer definition

The Rural Rescue Compact promises to direct 60 per cent of new road infrastructure to rural local government areas and publish quarterly scorecards for all 17 LGAs.

This is one of the more measurable commitments in the document, but it remains incomplete.

Sixty per cent of what exactly? The number of kilometres of roads? The total value of road contracts? The number of projects? The annual capital allocation for road construction?

These measures are not interchangeable.

The manifesto also fails to provide a baseline assessment of rural road conditions, identify priority routes or explain how projects would be selected. It does not state whether the 60 per cent allocation would apply every year or over the entire four-year administration.

A rural development policy should also extend beyond roads. It should address agricultural markets, schools, healthcare, electricity, water, digital connectivity, local enterprise and access to financial services.

The promise of one solar-powered water scheme in each ward is not, by itself, a comprehensive rural development programme.

12. The security proposal lacks operational and legal safeguards

The proposal to establish a statewide Command-and-Control Centre, supported by trained community security volunteers and forest guards in all 260 wards, is a major commitment.

But the manifesto does not explain the proposed security structure, the recruitment process, training standards, command arrangements, funding, intelligence-sharing mechanisms or accountability safeguards.

What would be the relationship between these volunteers and the Nigeria Police Force, the Department of State Services, the military and existing state security structures? Who would authorise operations? What rules would govern the use of force? How would complaints of abuse be investigated?

A security network covering 260 wards would require substantial funding, equipment, communication infrastructure, personnel management and continuous oversight.

The candidate also identifies specific highways and rural areas for security operations but provides no assessment of the nature of the threats in those locations or the resources needed to address them.

Security is too sensitive to be treated as a campaign slogan. It requires a carefully designed operational framework that protects both public safety and citizens’ rights.

13. The manifesto does not clearly distinguish state responsibilities from those of other tiers of government

A recurring weakness is the absence of clarity about the constitutional and administrative responsibilities involved in implementing some of the promises.

For example, the candidate promises to end multiple taxation and introduce a unified business assessment system. But taxation and revenue collection involve different levels of government and different legally authorised agencies. The state cannot simply announce the abolition or restructuring of every local government levy without explaining the legal and administrative arrangements through which that would happen.

The proposal to restore local government autonomy also needs more than a declaration. What institutional safeguards would ensure that councils exercise genuine financial and administrative independence? How would the state guarantee accountability at the local level? What arrangements would protect local government funds from diversion or mismanagement?

The same question applies to the proposed security network, land administration, electricity generation and public-private partnerships.

A candidate who promises to govern a state must demonstrate a clear understanding of the limits and powers of the state government, its relationship with the Federal Government, local councils, independent institutions and private-sector operators.

The manifesto rarely makes these distinctions.

14. The document is saturated with political grievances but does not explain the candidate’s alternative

Perhaps the most revealing feature of the manifesto is its language.

Expressions such as “reckless land acquisition”, “white elephant projects”, “opaque government transactions”, “poorly executed Smart Green Schools” and “political intimidation of dissenting voices” appear designed to create a picture of an administration that has failed across virtually every sector.

Yet the document provides little evidence to substantiate these sweeping characterisations.

This creates the impression that the manifesto is driven more by resentment towards the incumbent administration than by a carefully articulated vision of how Enugu should be governed.

The title, The Rescue Mission, reinforces this confrontational posture. There is nothing wrong with a candidate campaigning on the promise of change, but the language of rescue naturally invites a fundamental question: rescued from what, precisely, and on the strength of what evidence?

If the candidate believes that the state has been mismanaged, he should identify the specific decisions, policies and projects responsible. If he believes that the administration has displaced traders, imposed unjustifiable charges or mismanaged public resources, he should provide evidence and explain the legal and policy remedies.

Without that, the manifesto risks being interpreted as a document of political grievance rather than a credible programme for development.

There is also an important question of motive. The repeated emphasis on demolitions, land acquisition, market displacement and alleged intimidation gives the document a distinctly grievance-driven tone. It is reasonable to ask whether these issues have been selected because they represent the most pressing challenges facing Enugu or because they are politically useful points of confrontation with the incumbent government.

The manifesto does not provide enough evidence to establish the candidate’s personal motivation, and it would be unfair to claim that it does. However, its language and choice of emphasis create an impression of a political vendetta in search of a policy justification.

A governorship candidate should rise above personal or political grievances. The people of Enugu need a candidate who can explain how to improve their lives, not merely one who appears preoccupied with reversing the decisions of the person currently occupying the Government House.

15. There are structural inconsistencies and missing policy details

Beyond the substantive policy gaps, the manifesto also has problems with its organisation and internal consistency.

It announces five policy pillars but lists “Vision, Mission and Governing Philosophy” as one of them, even though these are not a clearly developed policy sector. The document then presents separate sections on the governing philosophy, the economy, governance, social services and rural development. The structure is therefore not as coherent as its introduction suggests.

There is also a gap between the promise of measurable results and the actual performance indicators provided.

The manifesto gives deadlines for some activities, such as setting up committees within seven days, submitting reports within 30 days and completing reviews within six months. But setting up committees and publishing reports are administrative outputs, not necessarily development outcomes.

For example, establishing a market recovery committee does not mean affected traders have been compensated. Completing a land policy review does not mean investors have greater confidence in the state’s land administration. Constructing a water scheme does not mean households receive clean and reliable water.

The document should distinguish between activities, outputs and actual outcomes.

It also needs to identify the responsible ministries, departments and agencies; the relevant funding sources; the implementation sequence; and the independent bodies that would monitor performance.

Without these, the promise to publish quarterly scorecards risks becoming another publicity exercise.

16. Some proposals are not sufficiently thought through

A number of other commitments deserve specific clarification:

– The end of mortuary taxation: The manifesto does not identify the particular charges it intends to abolish, the authorities collecting them or the legal basis for their collection.

– Tourism development: It lists several tourist attractions but provides no feasibility studies, investment model, access-road strategy, hospitality plan or environmental safeguards.

– Aviation: Positioning Akanu Ibiam International Airport as a gateway for trade and tourism is desirable, but the manifesto does not identify the specific state-level interventions that would achieve this ambition.

– Digital economy: ICT, innovation, digital skills and creative industries are mentioned, but there are no targets for training, job creation, startup financing, infrastructure or private-sector participation.

– Women’s economic empowerment: The proposal to promote access to credit, training and markets is commendable, but no financing structure, eligibility framework or implementation target is provided.

– Environmental protection: The promise to promote coal, natural gas and other mineral resources is not accompanied by an environmental impact framework, despite the manifesto’s simultaneous emphasis on sustainable development.

– Public-private partnerships: The candidate criticises questionable PPP arrangements but does not explain what standards, procurement rules or contractual safeguards would define acceptable partnerships under his administration.

These omissions reinforce the central concern: the manifesto identifies almost every desirable development objective but does not demonstrate how the objectives would be achieved.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here